SPAM-O-GRAM from JIM WATKINS (11

SPAM-O-GRAM from JIM WATKINS (11.10.05)

________________________________________

THIS WEEK’S ‘HEAVY TOPICS WITH A LIGHT TOUCH’

- HARRY POTTER: THE GOOD, THE BAD, THE MUGGLY

(see below)

- CAN ‘WAR ON TERRORISM’ BE WON?

Terrorists struck three five-star hotels in Amman Jordan yesterday killing nearly 70 people and

wounding many more. Meanwhile in Iraq, insurgents continued their bombings of civilian targets

seemingly unchecked. Can terrorism be stopped? I don't think so. Here's why . . .

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/terrorism05.htm

- UNINTELLIGENT DEBATE ON ‘INTELLIGENT DESIGN’

DNA may unravel evolutionary theory

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/index110605.htm#evolution

- GROUPS BATTLE OVER INTERPRETING CONSTITUTION, BIBLE

How different groups interpret the U.S. Constitution sounds very similar to how different groups interpret the Bible. What does the Bible REALLY say?

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/index110605.htm#constitution

- THE TWELVE SITES OF CHRISTMAS

Yikes! Just 40 + days until Christmas! Get into the spirit at:

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/indexc.htm

________________________________________

- HARRY POTTER: THE GOOD, THE BAD, THE MUGGLY

‘HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE” is ready to ignite more debate concerning the boy wizard. Critics are calling the film, which premiers next Friday, "darker and scarier." But is there anything to fear from the phenomenon?

Here’s a fiery debate--with myself . . .

HEADMASTER DUMBLEDORE: Good evening, muggles and wizards, and welcome to the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry's debate on "Harry Potter" with James Watkins and James Watkins. JIM is the author of THE WHY FILES: ARE THERE REALLY GHOSTS? and JIM is a newspaper columnist. Welcome gentlemen. We'll begin first with you, Jim.

JIM: Thank you, Headmaster Dumbledore. I've never debated myself before . . . at least in public . . . but thank you for this opportunity. First, I thoroughly enjoyed the book HARRY POTTER AND THE SORCERERS STONE. It is the story of a young boy who discovers that he is the son of wizards and goes off to Hogwarts to refine his wizardry. There, J. K. Rowling conjures up a fascinating world where good and evil collide with spells, invisibility cloaks, and a three-headed monster called "Fluffy," but good always triumphs in the end.

JIM: Good points, Jim, but one of the problems of the series, at least for children, is the moral ambiguity. We're never quite sure who is good and who is evil. Eleven-year-old Harry is a good boy, but he does have several character flaws. Dumbledore observes, he has "a certain disregard for rules." For adults, this makes realistic fiction. (Even in the Bible, Abraham, Moses, David, Peter, and others had major moral lapses.) But until children reach adolescence, they have difficulty understanding this complexity, so I wouldn't recommend the books for children younger than middle school.

JIM: I agree that Harry Potter is not for younger children. But what makes this book and the Warner Brothers movie outstanding is the author's refusal to allow a simplistic division of the characters into "good" and "evil" characters. As you pointed out, the Bible is filled with godly characters who did ungodly things. Such is life and part of maturity is understanding that our heroes - whether sports, music, or political - are apt to have some less than heroic qualities.

JIM: Good points, but the element of the supernatural has stirred up a caldron of controversy. Some Christians believe that the entire series violates both Old and New Testament commands to avoid witchcraft. For instance, Deuteronomy 18:10-12 warns: “Let no one be found among you who . . . practices divination or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft. . . . Anyone who does these things is detestable to the Lord.”

JIM: Yes, that's true, but is the "magic" in Harry Potter any different than the magic in C.S. Lewis' THE LION, THE WITCH, AND WARDROBE or in J. R. R. Tolkien's THE LORD OF THE RINGS? Conservative Christian and best-selling author, Charles Colson, argues that Harry and his friends, "develop courage, loyalty, and a willingness to sacrifice for one another. Not bad lessons in a self-centered world." He refers to the practices described in the books as: "purely mechanical, as opposed to occultic. That is, Harry and his friends cast spells, read crystal balls, and turn themselves into animals - but they don't make contact with a supernatural world…. [It is not] the kind of real-life witchcraft the Bible condemns." Obviously real witches do not fly brooms or turn into cats as they do in the books.

JIM: Interesting point. J. K. Rowling's world does seem to be more "secular" than "occult-ish." The witchcraft at Hogwart's doesn't include any of the elements of modern Wicca with its worship of nature and each other. However, the books do make witchcraft seem innocent and, of course, great fun. I think that's dangerous, particularly if they become a gateway to interest in hardcore Wicca or Satanic worship.

JIM: Granted. This book series is VERY different from Lewis' THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA, where the White Witch is undeniably evil and Aslan, the Christ-like lion, is purely good. I wouldn't mind my kids imitating Peter or Susan, but I don't want my kids to have Harry Potter as a role model.

JIM: Very true. I think our debate points out that this is a VERY complex issue. Harry Potter provides valuable lessons about love, courage, and the victory of good over evil. In fact famous journalist G. K. Chesterton claimed that his own journey into the Christian faith began with the lessons of good and evil, as well as self-sacrifice, found in fairy tales. On the other hand, I believe the motion picture industry was wise in giving the movie version a PG rating. The moral ambiguity makes the books and the movies inappropriate for elementary school students. Even the Bible, especially Genesis and Judges, has some X-rated material that is certainly not appropriate for young readers.

JIM: I agree with you completely, which shouldn't be surprising since I AM you. I mean, you're me. I mean . . . . I'm not sure debating myself was a good idea. Anyway, parents should read the books (or at least see the movie) if their children are reading them (and they probably are), as it provides opportunities to discuss the complex issues in the books which have become a very real part of youth culture.

________________________________________

PERSONAL NOTES, INFO

- WRITERS ON WRITING IS NOW AVAILABLE

I was editor on the ANTHOLOGY OF WRITING ADVICE from such people as JERRY “LEFT BEHIND” JENKINS and LIZ CURTIS HIGGS, plus editors from Guideposts, Zondervan, etc.

If you’d like an AUTOGRAPHED COPY send a check for $15.00 to

XarisCom

318 North Lenfesty Avenue

Marion, IN 46952

Or order online at:

http://www.parable.com/wph/item_M040405017.htm

- I’LL BE SPEAKING IN INDIANAPOLIS FRIDAY AND SATURDAY

I’m speaking at the WESLEYAN PUBLISHING HOUSE’S CHRISTIAN WRITERS’ WORKSHOP. Click for details:

http://www.wesleyan.org/writer

- THE WAIT GOES ON . . .

I just heard from my agent that a SIXTH BOOK PROPOSAL is being considered at Bethany House, Multnomah, NavPress and Regal. Pray that it finds a home at one of those houses.

Meanwhile, the wait goes on with five other proposals at Beacon Hill, Tyndale House and ZonderKids.

I am keeping busy speaking and freelance editing two books. God continues to provide through these projects and your support through PayPal (see below).

- LOIS AVAILABLE FOR COACHING, PREACHING, TEACHING

My wife is hanging out her shingle with her website that lists her many accomplishments and many WAYS SHE CAN ASSIST PASTORS AND CHURCHES:

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/loiscoach.htm

- MEMBERS ONLY SECTION

I’ve got some cool links and other stuff--just for SPAM-O-GRAM members. Just go to:

http://watkins.gospelcom.net/2n6M0F40c.htm

________________________________________

SPAM-O-GRAM IS BROUGHT TO YOU BY XARISCOM

I attempt to entertain, encourage, educate--and occasionally enrage--readers through my writing and speaking. It’s all part of my subversive plot to present a Christian worldview through:

JAMESWATKINS.COM’S ‘HEAVY TOPICS WITH A LIGHT TOUCH’ (http://www.jameswatkins.com)

ADULTSITE4ADULTS.COM (http://www.adultsite4adults.com)

and XARISCOM (http://www.xariscom.com).

BE A PAL . . .

If you believe in what I’m doing here, you can be a “pal” and help “pay” expenses for XARISCOM through PayPal. Just click http://www.xariscom.com for more information. (Go to http://watkins.gospelcom.net/2n6M0F40c.htm for my “snail mail” address if you prefer to send a check.)

________________________________________

FEEL FREE TO FORWARD THIS SLICE OF SPAM . . .

. . . on to all your email friends with the stipulation that you FORWARD IT IN ITS ENTIRETY INCLUDING THIS SHAMELESS COMMERCIAL AND COPYRIGHT NOTICE:

For "HEAVY TOPICS WITH A LIGHT TOUCH" (articles, book excerpts, editorials, and more) visit http://www.jameswatkins.com

________________________________________

TO UN-SUBSCRIBE . . .

You are receiving this recurring emailing because you either signed up on our website or made a direct request. (What were you thinking?!) We will spam no “SPAM“!

If some practical joker signed you up for the "SPAM-O-GRAM” against your will, or if you're simply cutting back on junk mail, send a blank email to:

SPAM-unsubscribe@jameswatkins.com

Sorry, but we can't be responsible for forwarded editions of “SPAM-O-GRAM.” (You really need to choose your email buddies more carefully!)